On The Doctor Who Forum (that used to be the Outpost Gallifrey Forum) somebody started a thread stating that they had heard from a very reliable source that Steven Moffat was definitely taking over as the Executive Producer/Head Writer on Doctor Who after the 2010 series had been broadcast. However, the BBC would neither confirm nor deny this until closer to the time when the handover occurs. I am very dubious about this, whenever I have seen Mr. Moffat talking about his career and in every interview with him that I have read, he makes it quite clear that he prefers working on things he has created himself and writing the occasional Doctor Who story is the only exception. So I think it is highly unlikely that he would want to concentrate all his talents on a series that was created by a committee back in 1963.
However, the thing that amazed me about the thread was one contributor who claimed that “Not even Steven Moffat could undo the damage done to Doctor Who by Russell T. Davies” . What!? Is the sky pink where this person lives. Bringing a moribund concept back from the dead and turning it into the most popular drama on British television can in no way be described as damaging Doctor Who. Having two successful series, Torchwood and The Sarah Jane Adventures spun-off from Doctor Who is not incurable harm to the series. So where this idiot, because idiot is the mildest thing I can call him, gets the idea that Doctor Who is damaged beyond repair from is beyond me. He is definitely diverging from reality. The thing is, Doctor Who fans are a rum bunch. They have a notion of how to make perfect Doctor Who and whenever the production team deviate from that notion, then it is the end of the World. This fool is probably cheesed of because Russell T. Davies has been making Doctor Who for the twenty first century, and he feels it should still be made the way he thinks Phil and Bob did it back in 1975.
Whilst I am on the subject of fan perceptions diverging from reality, lets kill another sacred cow. The Fans did nothing to bring the series back in 2005. The announcement of the return of Doctor Who had nothing to do with the Fans “keeping the flame alight” by buying the merchandise and campaigning. Anyone who thinks buying a series of books that was increasingly disappearing up its own bottom, a magazine that was starting to repeat itself for the fifth or sixth time or Big Finish’s faux-of-the-tv-recordings audio plays helped to keep Doctor Who in the eye of the people who run the BBC is deluding himself (I say himself because before 2005, Fandom was almost exclusively male). The announcement made on 26th September, 2003, was the product of a cold assessment of what the BBC needed to regain its traditional control over Saturday Night television. Steely eyed professionals saw a series that had once been popular and might be popular again. The fact that the people making the show are all Fans is a happy coincidence. Yes they are fans, but they knew that the reason the series died a death in the late 1980’s was because the show tried to please only the Fans, and they knew that they had to make as show that pleased the general audience first and the Fans second, just like Phil and Bob really did it back in 1975.
Anyway, back to the topic of Russell T. Davies’ departure from the top job. It wont happen until at least 2010 as he has said that he is staying on for the 2009 Specials and maybe longer. Also, I suspect that when Russell T. Davies does decide to move on, it is a racing certainty that his replacement as Executive Producer/Head Writer will not be Steven Moffat, Chris Chibnell, Matthew Graham or any of the other names mentioned by the Fans. It will be be a professional television writer who had had very little previous connection with the series. I said as much on one of the threads on The Doctor Who Forum, pulling the name Heidi Thomas from the hat because:
- She created Lillies, taking it from concept to finished series
- She has experience as an Executive Producer on Lillies
- She is a well respected writer who has created scripts for many popular series.
- She has worked with new Head of Drama at BBC Wales and incoming Doctor Who Executive Producer Piers Wenger on Granada’s recent successful adaptation of Noel Streetfield’s Ballet Shoes for the BBC.
- Is just the sort of non-fan breath of fresh air the series would need after the departure of Russell T. Davies.
The Sarah Jane Adventures have been commissioned for a second series, so I would not be at all surprised if Ms. Thomas is not asked to write a script for that series, or maybe even a script for the third series of Torchwood next year, followed by a two parter for Doctor Who Series Five in 2009 for broadcast in 2010. Although, to be perfectly honest I have no idea whether or not she is a fan of the series so the last point is just conjecture. As I said, this is just an educated guess, so if she does get the job, then you will be as gob-smacked as every other Doctor Who fan in the World.